Back

Your Brain Needs Progressive Overload, Too

Deb Blum·Apr 24, 2026· 5 minutes

What if the most unglamorous moments of your week — the healthier meal you chose, the workout you didn't want to do but you did it anyway, the decision you made from your bigger WHY instead of your feelings — are quietly building the most important thing you can build right now? Your brain's ability to protect itself. For decades. Here's the science that changed how I see everything.


"You're tired. You worked hard yesterday. You could go tomorrow. You deserve rest. You have too much to do. You can go later."

These are things my mind tells me when it's time to go to the gym. It's convincing and sometimes very loud.

A lot of people think I LOVE going to the gym and that it's easy for me. But it's not. Mostly, I tend toward being lazy. It would be so easy for me to become sedentary. And I don't usually WANT to go to the gym.

If I waited until I felt like it, I'd go maybe twice a month.

But each day, I make a decision that lives above my feelings — a bigger WHY that gets me out the door even when many other parts of me would rather not.

And here's what I've come to understand about that moment — that specific, hard, unglamorous moment of going anyway:

It is building my brain.

Let's talk about cognitive reserve.

Cognitive reserve is your brain's buffer — the cushion built up over a lifetime that allows it to keep functioning well even as it faces the wear of aging.

Scientists first noticed it when they autopsied brains in the 1980s and found something puzzling: some people had significant signs of Alzheimer's disease in their brain tissue, but had shown no memory loss or other symptoms of decline.

Their brains had built something that protected them. A reserve. A depth of neural resources that could absorb damage and keep going.

Think of it like this: two people, same amount of pathology in the brain.

One has built deep reserves.
One hasn't.
The one with reserve keeps functioning.
The other doesn't.
The difference isn't luck.
It's a lifetime of deposits.

Now here's where we need to blow up a myth.

When most people hear "brain health," they think: puzzles. Crosswords. Sudoku. Maybe a language app on your phone.

And yes — those things can help. But only if they're hard for you. Only if they're new. Only if they're asking your brain to do something it hasn't already mapped.

Because the engine of cognitive reserve isn't about activity.

It's effort.
It's novelty.
It's being asked to stretch.

Think about progressive overload in the gym — the principle that your muscles only grow when you give them a stimulus they haven't adapted to yet. The same weight, done forever, stops building anything. You have to go heavier. You have to change the movement. You have to keep introducing new challenges.

Your brain works the same way.

The crossword you've done a hundred times? Your brain barely shows up for it anymore. It's a pattern it already knows. So there's no stretch, so no reserve. (Of course, keep doing them if you love doing puzzles!)

But a conversation with someone who thinks differently than you?
A skill you've never tried?
A situation that demands you adapt in real time?
A game you've never played and have to learn?

That's the gym for your neurons.

Which brings us back to the decision to go to the gym.
And the negotiation.
And the choice to go anyway.

When you go to the gym, you build cognitive reserve through the exercise itself — movement is one of the most powerful brain-protective tools we have, full stop!

But on the days you don't want to go — and go anyway?

Something else is happening too.

Your prefrontal cortex — the seat of decision-making, long-term thinking, and self-regulation — lights up. It has to work hard to override the resistance. It has to hold your bigger WHY in mind while your feelings are pointing in the opposite direction.

That's effortful.
That's novel.
That is exactly the kind of challenge that builds neural depth.

You're not just training your body. You're training the part of your brain that makes you who you are.

These are the deposits. This is what builds the reserve.

Not an easy Tuesday.
Not the routine you could do in your sleep.
Not the conversation you've had a hundred times.

The hard thing.
The new thing.
The thing you did even though you didn't feel like it.

The future YOU who stays sharp, present, and fully yourself well into your later years is being built in those moments.

Not in the moments that feel good or easy.

In the moments you show up, even when it's NOT easy, natural, familiar, or comfortable.

What's one thing you did this week that you didn't feel like doing — but did anyway?

Drop it below. Let's celebrate the deposits. ↓

Ready to Come Home to Yourself?

Join my email community for guidance on The Whole Soul Way™—inner child healing, authentic living, and reclaiming yourself. As a welcome gift, you'll receive my Reparenting Your Inner Child guided audio to begin building the foundation of self-love and inner safety.

We hate spam too. Unsubscribe at any time.